Skip to main contentWebsite Accessibility Assistance

What's the Deal with Sharky's NSB Chicken Fingers?

What Is the Deal With Sharky's NSB Chicken Tenders?


What Is the Deal With Sharky's NSB Chicken Tenders?

Chicken tenders are the one dish everybody thinks they already know. Kids order them, grown adults order them, and most restaurants treat them like an afterthought: a bag out of the freezer, a dunk in the fryer, and a plastic cup of sauce on the side.

That's not how we do it at Sharky's NSB. I've spent 30 years in kitchens as a chef and restaurateur, and our tenders get the same scratch-kitchen treatment as everything else on our Refined Redneck menu. The proof is who's asking about them. We get a lot of adults, not kids, adults, stopping our servers to ask how we make our chicken tenders so darn good.

So here's the answer. These are the ten things that make our tenders different.

1. We Use Real Chicken Tenders, Not Cut-Up Breast Meat

This is the first thing most people don't realize. A lot of places take a chicken breast, slice it into strips, and call it a tender. That isn't a tender. A real chicken tender is the tenderloin, the small strip of muscle that sits underneath the breast. It's naturally more tender than the rest of the breast, and that's where the name comes from.

At Sharky's, we buy the actual tenderloin. You can taste the difference in the first bite.

2. We Buy Small Tenders From Smaller Birds

Here's a secret most diners never think about: size matters, and bigger isn't better. The large and extra-large tenders you see out there often come from oversized birds raised on hormones and antibiotics. That meat tends to be tougher and stringier.

We buy small, hormone-free chicken tenders. Smaller birds give you more tender meat, period. Quality starts long before anything hits our kitchen. It starts with what we choose to buy.

3. We Don't Need to Brine Them

A lot of kitchens brine their chicken to force tenderness and moisture into it. Brining has its place, and we do a three-day brine on our smoked turkey. But when you start with small, true tenderloins, the meat is already tender. We don't need to fix the chicken because we bought the right chicken in the first place.

4. Our Flour Is Seasoned In House With Our Own Blend

We start with premium flour and season it ourselves with a house recipe. I'll tell you some of what's in it: cayenne, thyme, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, and pepper. There are a few other ingredients I'm keeping to myself.

Think of it like the Colonel's secret blend of herbs and spices, except ours is made in a scratch kitchen on Flagler Avenue. That seasoning is in every layer of the crust, so the flavor goes all the way through instead of sitting on the surface.

5. We Use the Classic Dry, Wet, Dry Method

There's no shortcut batter here. Every tender goes through the classic three-step breading:

  • Dredge in our seasoned flour
  • Dip in buttermilk
  • Back into the seasoned flour for the final coat

That second flour layer is what builds the craggy, crunchy crust people love. The first layer gives the buttermilk something to grab onto, and the buttermilk gives the final coat something to stick to.

6. Full-Fat Buttermilk, Always

I always use full-fat buttermilk. Not low-fat, not a milk-and-vinegar substitute. Full-fat buttermilk clings better, adds a subtle tang, and helps the crust brown and crisp the right way. It's a small decision that most people would never notice on its own, but stack enough small decisions together and you get a tender people ask about.

7. Heavy Coat, Knock Off the Excess

We coat our tenders heavily in the seasoned flour. Then we knock off the excess before they go in the fryer.

That second part matters more than people think. Loose flour falls off in the fryer, burns, and dirties the oil. Dirty oil makes everything taste a little worse, not just the tenders, but the fries and everything else coming out of that fryer. Knocking off the excess keeps our oil clean, and clean oil means a cleaner, better-tasting crust.

8. Fried at 350 Degrees in a Vegetable and Olive Oil Blend

We fry our tenders at 350 degrees for about six minutes, or until they hit an internal temperature of 165 degrees. That's the sweet spot where the crust gets golden and crisp and the inside stays juicy.

We also use a vegetable and olive oil blend for all of our fried food. It's not the cheapest oil out there, but it fries clean and tastes better.

9. Scratch-Made Sauces, Led by Our Honey Mustard

Every sauce at Sharky's is made from scratch. Our tenders come with our honey mustard, and it's one of our most highly rated sauces. If honey mustard isn't your thing, you can also choose:

  • BBQ
  • Thai Sweet Chili
  • Ranch, the All-American sauce

10. The Insider Move: Hazard Sauce or Truffle Mayo

Want to order like a regular? Ask for your tenders with Hazard sauce. That's our house burger sauce, the one that goes on our Double Smash, and it's made with mayo, ketchup, mustard, and garlic-onion powder. If you're a fan of Raising Cane's sauce, you're going to like this one.

If you want to go fancy, try them with our housemade truffle mayo, the same one we put on our Smoked Turkey Sandwich. Crispy fried chicken with truffle mayo is about as Refined Redneck as it gets.

Why I Don't Order Chicken Tenders Anywhere Else

I'll be honest with you. I don't get chicken tenders anywhere else.

Our food isn't expensive, but it isn't cheap either, and there's a reason for that. There's an old saying I've lived by my whole career: good work ain't cheap, and cheap work ain't good. Real tenderloins, small hormone-free birds, a house seasoning blend, full-fat buttermilk, quality oil, and scratch sauces all cost more than a frozen bag of breaded strips. You can taste every one of those choices.

Come Try Them for Yourself

So what's the deal with Sharky's NSB chicken tenders? It's simple. We start with better chicken, we bread them by hand the right way, we fry them with care, and we make every sauce from scratch. That's why kids clean their plates and why grown adults keep asking us how we do it.

Come see us on Flagler Avenue in New Smyrna Beach. Order the tenders, grab the honey mustard, and ask for a side of Hazard sauce. Then you'll understand.


Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window