What Makes a Great Smashburger? A Chef's Take from Sharky's NSB
What Makes a Great Smashburger? A Chef's Take from Sharky's NSB
What Makes a Great Smashburger? A Chef's Take from Sharky's NSB
What Makes a Great Smashburger? Keep It Simple, Use Quality Ingredients
I've spent 30 years in kitchens, mostly as a chef and restaurateur, and here's what I've learned about smashburgers: the best ones are simple. No gimmicks, no towers of toppings, no fancy tricks. Just great beef, a hot flat-top, a soft bun, and a few toppings that know their role.
At Sharky's NSB on Flagler Avenue in New Smyrna Beach, our flagship is the Sharky's Double Smash. Here's how we build it, why we do it that way, and what you should (and shouldn't) do if you want to make a great smashburger at home.
How Staff Meals Shaped Our Smashburger
Every cook knows staff meal is where the real experimenting happens. When you're feeding your crew, you play with the food you already have, try different combinations, and see what everyone keeps coming back for.
That's how we refined the toppings on our smashburgers. Version after version, staff meal after staff meal, we figured out what belonged on the burger and what was just getting in the way. What survived is the lineup you'll find on the Double Smash today.
It Starts With the Beef
I can't stress this enough: quality, quality, quality. The better the beef, the better the burger. Period.
Use Ground Chuck at 80/20
We use ground chuck because it gives you the best ratio of beef to fat, right around 80/20. That fat is what keeps a thin patty juicy and gives you the flavor and crust that make a smashburger worth eating. Go too lean and you'll end up with something dry and forgettable.
Buy the Best Beef You Can Afford
My advice to home cooks is simple: buy the highest grade beef you can afford and you will have great burgers. The beef is the star. Everything else on the plate is there to support it.
Salt and Pepper, Always
Season every patty with salt and pepper. That's it. Good beef doesn't need much help.
The Sharky's Double Smash
Our flagship burger is built on two 3-ounce patties, seared hard with a good crust. Here's what goes on it:
- A Martin's Potato Roll
- Two 3-ounce smashed ground chuck patties
- American cheese
- Cold dill pickles
- Diced onion
- Our house Hazard sauce
We have a lot of other burgers on the menu, but most of them start from this same foundation with different toppings. Get the foundation right and everything else falls into place.
How to Smash a Burger the Right Way
The technique isn't complicated, but it does take attention and a little practice.
Heat Your Flat-Top Properly
A flat-top is the best tool for smashburgers. You can use a pan (it takes longer) or a grill pan on a traditional grill, but nothing beats a flat-top.
Keep it well oiled and set to medium-high heat. Most importantly, give it time to heat up. A lot of sticking problems come from cooking on a surface that isn't hot enough yet.
Add Clarified Butter Where the Beef Lands
At Sharky's, we add a little clarified butter to the spot where we lay the beef down. It helps with the sear and adds flavor without burning like whole butter would.
Smash It Thin, But Not Paper Thin
Lay the beef down, season with salt and pepper, then smash it with a steak weight and a spatula. We go thin, but not paper thin like some places do. You want a great crust on the outside while still tasting the beef.
Be Patient Before You Flip
Leave the patty on the first side for a good 3 to 4 minutes. Don't try to flip too early. That deep brown crust is the Maillard reaction doing its job, and if you rush it, the patty will stick to the flat-top and tear.
Flipping Takes Practice
Like anything in life, you get better at flipping patties and keeping them whole with practice. Your first few might fall apart. That's fine. Keep at it.
Why We Use American Cheese
We use American cheese a lot, and we love it. It's a great melting cheese and fits right in with our down-home, country-style menu. Honestly, I don't believe there's a better cheese for a burger or a grilled cheese. It melts smooth, coats the patty, and doesn't fight the beef for attention.
The Bun: Martin's Potato Rolls
For a simple smashburger, you can't beat a Martin's Potato Roll. They're delicious, soft, and in my opinion the gold standard for hamburger buns.
Size matters too. Make sure your bun isn't too big. A big, bready bun buries the beef, and you want to taste the quality beef you paid for.
Toppings and Our Hazard Sauce
Keep the Toppings Cold and Simple
Cold dill pickles and diced onion bring crunch, acid, and bite that cut through the richness of the beef and cheese. The contrast between a hot, crusty patty and cold pickles is part of what makes a smashburger so good.
Hazard Sauce
Our house burger sauce is called Hazard sauce. It's a mix of mayo, ketchup, mustard, and garlic-onion powder. Tangy, savory, and creamy, it ties the whole burger together.
We Only Use Duke's Mayo
At Sharky's, we only use Duke's mayo. It costs more, but we love the quality and the taste. That's a choice we make across the kitchen: always choose quality ingredients. It makes you look like a better cook.
Common Smashburger Mistakes to Avoid
Most smashburger problems come down to a handful of mistakes:
- Using cheap beef. You can't fix low-quality meat with toppings or sauce.
- Overcooking the patty. A thin patty cooks fast. Go too far and it turns dry.
- Flipping too early. Give the crust time to form, or the patty will stick and tear.
- Not preheating the flat-top. A cold surface is the number one cause of sticking.
- Using a bun that's too big. The bun should hold the burger, not overpower it.
- Piling on too many toppings. Like pizza, don't put too many toppings on it. Let the beef shine.
The One Thing to Remember
If you take away one thing from this post, make it this: keep it simple with quality ingredients.
Great beef, salt and pepper, a hot flat-top, American cheese, a Martin's roll, and a few cold, crunchy toppings. That's what makes a great smashburger. Come down to Sharky's NSB on Flagler Avenue and try the Double Smash for yourself.