Smoked Turkey Sando at Sharky's NSB
How's the Smoked Turkey So Good?
How Sharky's Smoked Turkey Got So Good (And Why Our Turkey Sandwich Converts People)
The Turkey Sandwich People Say They Can't Get Anywhere Else
Turkey has a reputation problem. Most people think of it as the safe, boring option, the sandwich you order when nothing else on the menu sounds right. At Sharky's NSB on Flagler Avenue, we set out to change that, and judging by what our guests tell us, it worked. We've had customers tell us flat out that they won't eat turkey anywhere else anymore.
That doesn't happen by accident. After 30 years in hospitality, mostly as a chef and restaurateur, I've learned that great food usually comes down to respecting the ingredient and refusing to take shortcuts. Our smoked turkey is a perfect example of both. Here's exactly how we do it, and why the Smoked Turkey Sandwich has become one of the dishes our regulars expect to see on the menu every single day.
Why Turkey Is So Easy to Get Wrong
Lean proteins are harder to cook than fatty ones. Fat is forgiving. It bastes the meat, carries flavor, and gives you some wiggle room if you leave something on the heat a little too long. Turkey breast has almost none of that cushion, which is why so much of the turkey people eat ends up dry, stringy, and bland.
The first thing you need to think about with any lean protein is the cooking method. With turkey, there are several good options. Frying and smoking are my two favorites, and roasting works well too. But no matter which method you pick, the real key to great turkey is the brine.
The Secret Is a 3-Day Brine
Most people who brine turkey go for about 24 hours. We add two more days on top of that. Yes, our turkey breast sits in the brine for three full days before it ever sees the smoker.
Here's why. Turkey breast is so lean that it needs all the help it can get holding onto moisture. A longer brine lets the salt and sugar work their way deep into the meat, which helps the protein retain its juiciness through a three-hour smoke. The result is better depth of flavor and a much moister slice than you'll get from a quick overnight soak.
What Goes Into the Brine
We keep our brine slightly on the sweet side. It's built from:
- Water
- Salt
- Sugar
- Garlic
- Rosemary
The sweetness plays beautifully with the cherry wood smoke later on, and the garlic and rosemary give the meat an herbal backbone that ties right into the bread we serve it on.
Why We Take the Skin Off First
We use turkey breast only, starting with an average of about 8 pounds, which is two lobes of breast. Before it goes into the brine, we clean the skin off. Skin acts like a barrier, and pulling it off lets the brine soak directly into the meat so every bite carries that flavor.
How We Smoke It
Seasoning After the Brine
When the turkey comes out of the brine, we let it dry and then hit it with our pepper blend. Notice what's missing: salt. After three days in the brine, the meat already has all the salt it needs. Adding more at this stage is a common way people end up with turkey that tastes like a salt lick.
Cherry Wood and 300 Degrees
We smoke on an offset barrel smoker using cherry wood. Cherry gives a mild, slightly sweet smoke that complements the brine instead of overpowering the turkey. We bring the smoker up to 300 degrees before the turkey goes in, then let it ride for roughly three hours, or until it hits 165 degrees on an internal thermometer.
Never Smoke It Longer Than 3 Hours
This is one of my firm rules. I won't leave turkey breast in the smoker past three hours, because that's when it starts to dry out. If the breast hasn't reached 165 by then, don't keep pushing it in the smoke. Instead, braise it the rest of the way up to 165 and let it rest in the liquid. You keep the smoke flavor you've already built and protect all that moisture you worked three days to lock in.
Slicing It Right
Once the turkey hits 165, it's ready. Grab a super sharp knife or a serrated knife and carve. Slice it thick or thin, however you like it. A clean cut with a sharp blade keeps the slices intact instead of shredding the meat.
What Makes the Smoked Turkey Sandwich So Great
At Sharky's, we call our food Refined Redneck Cuisine, and this sandwich captures that idea better than almost anything on our menu. It's still a turkey sandwich at heart. We just took every component of the humble classic and leveled it up.
The Build
- Rosemary focaccia roll instead of plain sandwich bread, which echoes the rosemary in our brine
- Housemade truffle mayo in place of regular mayo
- Arugula instead of iceberg lettuce, for a peppery bite that stands up to the smoke
- Classic tomato slices, because some things don't need fixing
- Red onion for sharpness and crunch
- Our house-smoked, 3-day-brined turkey breast, the star of the show
Every sandwich comes with our housemade cajun potato chips on the side.
Familiar, But Better
That's the whole philosophy behind Refined Redneck. We're not trying to turn a turkey sandwich into something unrecognizable. We want you to bite into something that feels comfortable and familiar, and then realize it's the best version of it you've ever had. That's exactly what most first-timers tell us.
How the Sandwich Evolved
We started smoking turkey shortly after Sharky's opened in April 2025. It was good from day one, but we haven't stopped tinkering since. Over time we've refined the brine, dialed in the smoke time, adjusted the pepper blend, and reworked the sandwich itself.
It actually started life on our menu as a smoked turkey club. As we kept refining it, the club gave way to the sandwich we serve today, a cleaner build that lets the turkey shine while every other ingredient pulls its weight. That kind of constant improvement is how we approach the whole menu.
More Ways to Get Our Smoked Turkey
If you're coming in for brunch, our smoked turkey also shows up in the Nashville Hot Turkey Biscuit with gravy. It's the same turkey with a completely different personality, spicy, rich, and about as Southern as breakfast gets.
Can You Always Get It?
The Smoked Turkey Sandwich is on the menu every day, unless we sell out. Because of that three-day brine, we can't just whip up a fresh batch on the spot. Every so often we run out and go without it for a couple of days while the next round finishes brining. We work hard to keep it in stock, though, because our customers have come to expect it on the menu all the time, and we try to oblige.
If you've ever written off turkey as the boring option, come see us on Flagler Avenue in New Smyrna Beach and give this sandwich a shot. Just don't be surprised if it ruins every other turkey sandwich for you.
Tips If You Want to Try This at Home
If you're planning to smoke a turkey breast for Thanksgiving or any other occasion, here's what I'd take away from how we do it at Sharky's:
- Start brining three days ahead, not the night before
- Take the skin off before brining so the flavor gets into the meat
- Go slightly sweet with the brine and include garlic and rosemary
- Season with pepper after the brine, but skip the salt
- Smoke at 300 degrees over a mild fruitwood like cherry
- Pull it at 165 degrees internal, and never smoke it longer than three hours
- If it needs more time, finish it in a braise and rest it in the liquid
- Carve with a very sharp or serrated knife
Turkey doesn't have to be dry and forgettable. Give it the time and respect it needs, and it can be the best thing on the table.
