Redneck Margarita at Sharky's
7 Reasons the $5 Redneck Margarita Is the Best Everyday Drink on Flagler Avenue
7 Reasons the $5 Redneck Margarita Is the Best Everyday Drink on Flagler Avenue
I've spent 30 years in hospitality, mostly as a chef and restaurateur, and I've had more margaritas than I'd admit to my doctor. I love a fancy one. But the margarita I really love, the one I'd drink on any given Tuesday, is simple, consistent, and doesn't cost a small fortune. That's the drink we built at Sharky's NSB, and we call it the Redneck Margarita.
Here are seven things you should know about it before you pull up a stool.
1. It Costs $5, Every Hour We're Open
Most margarita deals come with fine print. Two hours in the afternoon, weekdays only, house well only, and you'd better be off work early to catch it.
We didn't want that. We wanted a great drink at a great price for every hour our doors are open, not just a short window in the afternoon. Lunch, sunset, late night, it's five bucks.
We still run a happy hour, and every Friday from 3 to 6 PM we do 2-for-1. But the Redneck Margarita isn't a happy hour gimmick. It's an everyday price for an everyday drink.
Around here we like to joke that the only time you can't get a good deal on a margarita on Flagler is when Sharky's is closed.
2. It's Built for Our Regulars
We have folks who come in several times a week. They're the backbone of this place, and they shouldn't have to time their visits around a happy hour clock to get a fair price on a good drink.
The Redneck Margarita is our way of saying thanks to them. Come in whenever it suits you, sit down, and know the price will be the same as last time. Consistency matters to regulars, both in what's in the glass and in what's on the bill.
3. The Recipe Is Simple on Purpose
There's no secret here, and there's nothing fussy about it. Here's what goes into every Redneck Margarita:
- Silver tequila
- Triple sec
- Sour mix
- Orange juice
- Lime juice
It's served on the rocks, with or without a salted rim, your call.
As a chef, I can tell you that simple is hard to get right. When a recipe only has a handful of ingredients, there's nowhere for mistakes to hide. The orange juice rounds out the tartness of the lime and sour, and the silver tequila keeps it clean and bright. Super simple, and super delicious.
4. We Love Fancy Margaritas Too
Don't get me wrong. If you want to spend real money on tequila, we've got you covered. We pour top-shelf bottles like Don Julio 1942 and Clase Azul, and there's a time and place for sipping something special.
But I don't think a great margarita has to be expensive. The Redneck Margarita is the one we'd recommend to a friend who just wants a good, honest drink that tastes the same every time. Save the top shelf for celebrations. The Redneck is for everything else.
5. It's Stronger Than You Think
I'll be straight with you, because I'd rather you hear it from me than find out the hard way. These are strong.
They go down easy, which is exactly the problem. One is a pleasure. Two is a good time. After two, they start catching up with you fast. Pace yourself, drink some water, eat something, and get a ride if you need one. We want to see you back here next week.
6. It Pairs Perfectly With Our Southern Meatballs
If you ask me what to eat with a Redneck Margarita, my answer is our Southern Meatballs appetizer every time.
What's in the Southern Meatballs
- Three meatballs made in house from a grass-fed ground chuck blend
- Tossed in our house-made BBQ sauce
- Served on a bed of cheesy grits
- Topped with green onions and crispy onions
Why the Pairing Works
That dish is rich. You've got smoky, sweet BBQ, creamy cheesy grits, and fried crispy onions on top. It's comfort food through and through.
The margarita's citrus and acidity cut right through all that richness. Somehow the dish feels lighter with every sip. If you go with salt on the rim, it plays off the sweetness of the BBQ, too. It's a chef's pairing that makes total sense once you try it.
7. The Name Says Everything About Sharky's
Our food philosophy at Sharky's NSB is what we call Refined Redneck Cuisine. We take Southern comfort, coastal flavor, and scratch cooking and give them a little polish without losing the soul.
The Redneck Margarita follows the same idea. The margarita is a Mexican classic and one of our favorite cocktails in the world. We put a Southern tag on it and made it our own. It's an affordable, honest, no-frills drink that fits right in at a beach bar on Flagler Avenue.
Come Try One for Yourself
Whether you're a local who stops in a few times a week or you're visiting New Smyrna Beach for a weekend, the $5 Redneck Margarita is waiting for you at Sharky's NSB on Flagler Avenue. Order it on the rocks, salt or no salt, add a plate of Southern Meatballs, and take it easy after the second one.
We'll see you at the bar.

